Plagiarism and Similarity Policy
Last updated: 1 November 2026.
Definition
Plagiarism is the use of another person’s words, ideas, results, or structure without proper attribution, including text taken from the author’s own earlier work (self-plagiarism) and the uncredited translation of another’s work.
Tool and stages
JCP checks manuscripts with Turnitin at desk evaluation and again on the final version before publication. The report is stored in the editorial archive.
Threshold and assessment
A similarity index above 20% results in the manuscript being returned to the author for revision and resubmission. The index is a screening signal, not a verdict. The editor reads the report, excluding the bibliography and properly marked quotations, and decides on substance. A manuscript below the threshold can still be plagiarised (for example, paraphrase without credit or copied ideas), and one above it can be acceptable (for example, many documented quotations from primary sources).
Acceptable and unacceptable similarity
Acceptable: quotations with quotation marks or block indentation and citation; reference lists; titles and catalog references; standard terms, formulae and method descriptions; a preprint, thesis or presentation version disclosed to the editor. Unacceptable: unmarked verbatim text; close paraphrase without citation; copying others’ ideas, results or structure; reuse of the authors’ own published text without disclosure and permission; duplicate submission.
Levels and sanctions
|
Level |
Description |
Action |
|
Minor |
A short passage taken without significant ideas or data |
Warning; author corrects the text and cites the source |
|
Intermediate |
A significant portion used without credit |
Rejection; submission ban of one year |
|
Severe |
Reproduction of results or ideas of another publication |
Rejection; submission ban of five years |
|
Repeat case |
Second case by the same authors |
Decision by the editorial board; a permanent ban is possible |
Self-plagiarism: significant overlap (identical or almost identical figures and text for half or more of the paper) is treated as severe; overlap of between one-tenth and one-half as intermediate; overlap limited to methods as minor. All authors of a manuscript share the same sanction. Authors may respond to the allegation and appeal under Complaints and Appeals before a sanction takes effect. The list of sanctioned authors is held confidentially by the Managing Editor and used only to screen submissions.
Before and after publication
Before publication: the manuscript is returned or rejected as above. After publication: the editor follows the procedure in Publication Ethics section 15 and issues a correction, expression of concern or retraction as appropriate.
Republication and translation
Material published elsewhere, including conference papers or articles in another language, requires disclosure of the source, the copyright holder’s permission and the editor’s approval. A deliberate republication of a historic text is labeled as such and cites the original.