Last updated: 20 November 2026

Handling Allegations of Misconduct
JCP follows COPE guidance when it receives an allegation of misconduct before or after publication. Misconduct includes plagiarism; fabrication or falsification of data, sources, quotations, or consent; fabricated references (including those produced by AI); duplicate submission or publication; authorship violations; manipulation of peer review or citations; undisclosed conflicts of interest; unethical research; and breaches of confidentiality.

A. Receiving an allegation
Allegations may be sent to yudhiandoni@hum.unand.ac.id by anyone, with as much evidence as possible. JCP also investigates concerns it finds itself (for example, a similarity report or a reviewer’s concern). All allegations are kept confidential and recorded.

B. Procedure
1) Acknowledge the sender within 7 days.
2) Initial assessment by the Editor-in-Chief and at least one other editor without a conflict of interest, within 14 days: Is the allegation credible, serious, and within JCP’s remit? If not, the sender is told why.
3) Inform and invite response. The authors (or reviewers, editors) are informed of the substance of the allegation and given 14 days to respond in writing, with supporting evidence.
4) Evidence. The editors may check sources, similarity reports, data, consent records, and OJS records, and may consult independent experts.
5) Institution. If misconduct is probable, or the authors do not cooperate, JCP informs the authors’ institution or funder and asks it to investigate, and follows COPE guidance on the institution’s response. JCP does not wait for the institution when published work is clearly unreliable.
6) Decision within 30 days of the initial assessment, where possible, with a written decision by at least three editors. Possible outcomes: no action; educational letter or warning; correction; expression of concern; retraction; rejection of a manuscript under review; sanction under the Plagiarism Policy; and notification of institutions, funders, or indexing services.
7) Appeal under Complaints and Appeals.

C. Principles
- Persons accused are presumed to have acted in good faith until the evidence shows otherwise, and have the chance to respond.
- Editors with a conflict of interest take no part.
- Information is shared only with those who need it, but JCP may inform other journals or institutions when required to protect the scholarly record.
- A report made in good faith is never penalized, even if it is not upheld.

D. Record keeping
JCP keeps a confidential record of every case, the evidence, and the decision for three years. Aggregated figures are published in the annual transparency report.