Conflict of Interest Policy
Conflict of Interest Policy
A conflict of interest (competing interest) exists when a financial, professional, personal, institutional, or ideological relationship could reasonably be seen to influence, or to appear to influence, the writing, review, or editorial handling of a manuscript. Conflicts are not wrong in themselves; undisclosed conflicts are.
- Authors
Authors must disclose in a “Conflict of Interest” statement every relationship that might be seen as influencing their work, in the three years before submission: employment or affiliation with an organization that has an interest in the subject; funding; personal, family, or close professional ties with reviewers or editors; and being a member of the editorial team or reviewer pool of JCP. If none, the statement reads: “The author(s) declare no conflict of interest.” The statement appears in the declaration sheet of the published article. Failure to disclose a major conflict may lead to correction or retraction.
- Reviewers
Reviewers must decline an invitation, and tell the editors, if they: are from the same institution as an author or have collaborated, co-authored, or supervised in the last five years; have a personal or financial relationship with an author; compete with the authors on the same project; or can identify the authors and cannot review impartially. Reviewers must not use information from a manuscript for their own benefit.
- Editors
Editors must declare conflicts that affect the handling of a manuscript (the same grounds as for reviewers, plus a current supervisory, employment, or funding relationship with an author). An editor with a conflict does not see the reviewer identities, reports, or decision on that manuscript, and the system is configured so that they cannot access them (OJS stage restriction). Editors keep a written record of their declarations.
- Manuscripts by editors, reviewers, and the publisher
- A manuscript written by the Editor-in-Chief, a Managing Editor, an editorial team member, a Secretariat member, a Layout/Production Editor, or an employee of the editorial office is handled by an independent editor with no connection to the authors. The author-editor is excluded from all steps of that manuscript in OJS, including reviewer selection, the editorial decision, and production.
- If the Editor-in-Chief is an author, a Managing Editor or editorial team member who is not an author makes all decisions; if none is available, an external guest editor is appointed by the Editorial Team.
- These manuscripts are peer-reviewed, double-blind, by at least two external reviewers, who do not know that an editor is involved.
- The published article carries the note: “One or more authors are members of the JCP editorial team. This article was handled independently by an independent editor, and the authors had no access to the review.” Dates of receipt and acceptance are always shown.
- To protect independence, no more than 10% of the research articles in an issue, and no more than two articles per person per issue as author, may come from members of the editorial team or reviewer pool.
- Manuscripts from the authors’ own institution should not exceed one third of an issue.
- Publisher, funders, and partners
The Faculty of Humanities, its partners (the Kato Institute and the Masyarakat Sejarawan Indonesia), and its funders may not influence the selection of manuscripts, reviewers, or decisions. Any approach of this kind must be reported to the Editor-in-Chief and the Editorial Team, and is recorded.
- Handling declared conflicts
The handling editor checks declarations at submission, at reviewer invitation, and before the decision. If a conflict is found later, the editors may suspend the review, appoint another editor or reviewer, or, after publication, publish a correction (see Corrections, Retractions and Expressions of Concern). Concerns about conflicts may be reported under Complaints and Appeals.
Last updated 20 November 2026.