Reviewer Guidelines
Reviewer Guidelines
Thank you for reviewing for JCP. Your work protects the quality of scholarship in history and literature.
- Before you accept
- Accept only if the manuscript is within your expertise, you can return the report within 2–4 weeks, and you have no conflict of interest (see Conflict of Interest Policy).
- If you think you know the authors, or have seen the manuscript before, tell the editors.
- Do not discuss the manuscript with others without the editors’ permission.
- Confidentiality and AI
The manuscript and your report are confidential. Do not upload any part of them to generative AI tools, and do not use such tools to analyze, summarize, or draft the report or to improve its language. Do not contact the authors.
- What to assess
|
Aspect |
Questions |
|
Originality and contribution |
Does the article make a new argument, use new sources, or reinterpret known ones? Is it significant for history or literature? |
|
State of the art and research gap |
Does the introduction place the study in current scholarship, and identify a clear gap and problem? |
|
Sources and method |
Are sources appropriate, correctly identified, critically assessed, and cited with precision? Is the method sound for a historical or literary study? Is the concept or theory applied consistently? |
|
Argument and analysis |
Do the findings answer the research questions? Is the argument supported by evidence? Are alternative interpretations considered? |
|
Structure and clarity |
Are the abstract, structure, and conclusions consistent? Is the language clear? |
|
References |
Are references current, relevant, and complete, with a majority from primary scholarly sources? Do any appear fabricated? |
|
Ethics |
Is there any plagiarism, duplicate publication, missing consent or permission, or undisclosed AI use? Is the declaration sheet complete? |
Comments must address the substance. Please do not limit your report to language, formatting, or layout, which the editorial office checks separately.
- Review form
- Recommendation: accept; minor revisions; major revisions; decline.
- Summary of the manuscript in your own words (3–5 sentences).
- Main strengths.
- Main concerns, numbered, with the page or section, and specific suggestions for how to address each.
- Ethical concerns (to the editors only, in confidence).
- Confidential comments to the editors.
- Declaration: “I have no conflict of interest, and I did not use generative AI tools in this review.”
- Tone and timing
Be constructive, specific, and courteous, and avoid personal comments. If you need more time, tell the editors early. Review reports are kept in OJS as part of the editorial record.
- Recognition
With your consent, your name is listed in the annual acknowledgment of reviewers.